Hey Comrade, when it comes to answering case law questions in law subjects, especially those coming from non-legal backgrounds, might feel overwhelmed when you first encounter case law questions in examinations. But don’t worry – I’m here to guide you through this step by step how to answer each type of question and the most important rules you should keep in your mind before answering these questions and one model answer i have written for your reference,
Case Law Questions- IMP Rules
A. Why Case Law Questions Are Different
Unlike your other graduation subjects where you might memorize and reproduce facts, law examinations require a completely different approach. These questions test your analytical thinking, legal reasoning, and practical application of legal principles. They’re designed to see if you can think like a lawyer!
Case law questions typically carry 10-15 marks and require you to demonstrate not just knowledge, but understanding and application. The good news? Once you master the format, these questions become much more manageable.
Here’s a reality check, comrade: Don’t expect to score well if you write brief, internal exam-style answers for these case-law questions. The marking scheme is designed to reward detailed, analytical responses that demonstrate your understanding of legal principles and their practical application.
B. The Art of Clear and Logical Flow
One of the most important aspects of a good legal answer is that it should be crystal clear and have a logical flow in your argument. Think of your answer as telling a story – each paragraph should naturally lead to the next, rather than jumping randomly from one unrelated point to another.
Imagine you’re explaining a complex legal issue to a fellow student who’s hearing about it for the first time. Your explanation should be so clear and well-structured that they can follow your reasoning without getting confused or lost along the way.
C. The Golden Rule of Relevance
Here’s where many students lose precious marks: sticking to the case facts and issues involved in the question is absolutely crucial. It’s much more important than writing extensively about unrelated topics, even if you’ve prepared those topics really well.
Let me give you a practical example: if the question is specifically about the conditions of a valid contract, then your entire answer should focus on those conditions. Don’t get tempted to write three pages about just one aspect like “consideration” or “acceptance” while ignoring the other essential elements. The examiner wants to see that you understand all the relevant conditions, not that you’re an expert on just one of them.
D. Avoiding Irrelevant Content
I know it’s incredibly tempting – you’ve spent hours preparing a particular topic, you know it inside out, and suddenly you see a question that’s somewhat related. Your first instinct might be to showcase all that knowledge, even if it’s not directly relevant to what’s being asked.
Resist this temptation! It’s very easy to deviate from the actual facts of the case while writing that lengthy answer for 10 marks. However, expanding on and writing about topics that are directly related to the given issues will fetch you much better marks than focusing on unrelated topics just because you’ve prepared those topics more thoroughly.
Think of it this way: the examiner has a specific marking scheme in mind. If you spend half your answer discussing irrelevant points, you’re essentially wasting valuable space and time that could have been used to address what’s actually being asked.
E. The Simple but Powerful Principle
Here’s a principle that will serve you well throughout your law studies: Simply answer only what’s asked. No extra unrelated content to make your answer unnecessarily lengthy.
Why is this so important? Because when you include irrelevant information, it not only wastes space but can actually reduce the marks you get for your other correct answers. Examiners appreciate concise, relevant responses over lengthy, unfocused ones.
F. Reading and Understanding: Your First Step to Success
Before you even start writing, take time to carefully read the question – especially if it’s a case-study type question. Identify:
- What exactly is being asked?
- What are the key facts?
- What legal issues are involved?
- What type of response is expected?
This initial analysis will guide your entire answer and prevent you from going off-track.
G. Clarity Equals Marks
Here’s something that will change how you approach your answers: Remember, the less you confuse the lecturer who is correcting your answer, the more marks they will give you.
Put yourself in the examiner’s shoes – they’re reading dozens, maybe hundreds of answer papers. They appreciate answers that are:
- Well-organized with clear headings and subheadings
- Easy to follow with logical progression
- Directly relevant to the question asked
- Comprehensive but not unnecessarily lengthy
When an examiner can quickly identify your key points and follow your reasoning, they’re more likely to give you the marks you deserve.
H. Practical Tips for Implementation
Before Writing:
- Read the question twice to fully understand what’s being asked
- Identify the key legal issues involved
- Plan your answer structure with appropriate headings
While Writing:
- Stick to your planned structure
- Use clear, simple language
- Support your arguments with relevant case laws and legal principles
- Keep referring back to the question to ensure you’re staying on track
After Writing:
Check that your answer flows logically from one point to the next
Quickly review to ensure you’ve answered what was asked
The Five Types of Law Questions and How to Answer Them
1. Theory-Based/Direct Questions
Example: “Explain the essentials of a valid contract and discuss when agreements become void.”
Your Answer Structure:
- Introduction: Brief overview of the topic
- Concept Explanation: Define key terms clearly
- Legal Framework: Explain relevant legal provisions
- Supporting Case Laws: Cite relevant judicial decisions
- Conclusion: Summarize your main points
2. Statement-Based Questions
Example: “All contracts are agreements, but all agreements are not contracts” – Explain.
Your Answer Structure:
- Statement Interpretation: Break down what the statement means
- Topic Introduction: Detailed explanation of both concepts mentioned
- First Concept Analysis: Deep dive with case laws
- Second Concept Analysis: Comparative analysis with case laws
- Conclusion: How the statement holds true with examples
3. Case Study Questions (The Big One!)
Example: “A sold goods to B on credit, not knowing B was a minor. When B attained majority, A sued for payment. Will A succeed?”
Your Answer Structure – The IRAC Method:
Facts Summary: Briefly restate the given scenario
Issues: What legal questions need to be resolved?
- “Whether a contract with a minor is valid?”
- “Whether a minor can be held liable after attaining majority?”
Rules: State the applicable legal principles
- “Contracts with minors are void ab initio”
- “Section X of the Contract Act states…”
Analysis: Apply the law to the facts
- “In this case, since B was a minor when the contract was made…”
- “The principle established in Mohori Bibee vs. Dharmodas Ghose applies here…”
Conclusion: Your final judgment
- “Therefore, A will not succeed in his claim because…”
4. Legal Advice Questions
Example: “Mr. Ashok emailed Mr. Raghu offering to sell his plot for Rs. 2 lakhs. When Raghu arrived with money, Ashok refused to sell. Advise Raghu.”
Your Answer Structure:
- Simple Language: Write as if speaking to a client (no heavy legal jargon)
- Available Remedies: What legal options does the client have?
- Pros and Cons: Advantages and disadvantages of each option
- Practical Advice: Clear, actionable recommendations
- Final Recommendation: Your best advice for the client
5. Distinguish/Compare Questions
Example: “Differentiate between fraud and misrepresentation in contract law.”
Your Answer Structure:
- Individual Introductions: Explain each concept separately
- Tabular Comparison: Create a clear comparison table
- Detailed Analysis: Elaborate on key differences with examples
- Concluding Remarks: Brief summary of when each applies
Download- Model Answer for Case Law Questions [Click Here]
Keep practising these formats, and soon you’ll find that case law questions become one of your strengths rather than a source of anxiety.
--About Me--
"My primary goal with this website is to provide all-in-one notes and list of important questions for each subject to help you complete your law degree effectively.
If you're curious about the person behind these articles, click on personal world to know my personal side and my different interests, Ravi Yalavarthi's Personal World."
--For Professional Enquiries Use This Contact Form--